Illinois basketball chat: 12:30 p.m. Wednesday

Wednesday, November 5, 2008 - 12:30pm

Talk with Illinois men's basketball beat writer Paul Klee

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:26 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Good afternoon everyone. Thanks for coming by the weekly Illinois/college basketball chat. The best time of year is upon us.

The college basketball season opens Monday with Presbyterian at Duke (ESPNU). Purdue will be watching

Carl from Joliet, IL — 12:27 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Do you think the Big 10 can win the Big 10/ACC challenge this year? I am saying that the ACC wins this year, but the BIG 10 will crush the ACC in the next couple years with the outstanding recruiting of Purdue, Minnesota, Illinois, Ohio State, Michigan State, Indiana ( All top 25 class in 2009, 2010).

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:30 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Carl- No, I don't see the Big Ten winning the Challenge this season.

A) The matchups don't favor the Big Ten. I see seven wins for the ACC.

B) The ACC is better. Before the Big Ten crushes the ACC, it needs to simply become competitive (0-9).

Michigan State (5-3) is the only Big Ten team that has a winning record in the Challenge. The Spartans are also involved in the marquee game of this year's Challenge

Mitch from Barry, Illinois — 12:31 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Paul, who has the best mid-range jumpshot on this years team? Will Webers motion offense get a lot of open look 12-15 foot jumpshots with the pick and roll?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:32 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Mitch- Alex Legion has a refined mid-range game. He's spent hours working on that shot since he arrived in January, coming around invisible screens or chairs at the team

Rob A. from Oswego, NY — 12:33 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

How deep do you think Coach Weber will go this year? I count five bigs (Semrau, Davis, Tisdale, Keller, Cole), and five guards (Brock, Frazier, Jordan, Meacham, McCamey)--not even counting Legion. Who is the odd man out?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:38 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Rob- Bruce Weber said he wants to use these two exhibition games to help trim the playing rotation to 8 or 9 guys. That's as deep as he wants to go, to get a more fluid substitution pattern. I'm sure that rotation will evolve during the season, but he would like to enter the season with a rough draft.

The odd man out? Whoever doesn't defend.

And Weber wants a second defensive stopper. He used Jeff Jordan as an example of one candidate for that role.

"Last year we had Brian Randle and Chester (Frazier). We had two of the best defensive players in the league," Weber said. "They could just limit people. I don't think we can do that. We have to do it as a team, help each other out."

Klee

David from Savoy, IL — 12:39 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Will Daniel Dufrene be the starting running back for the Illini when they face Western Michigan? Troy Pollard looked very impressive last season, why hasn't he played much this season - is he still not 100%? Thanks.

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:40 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

David- I polled Bob Asmussen, our football writer, for his thoughts on your question. Here's what Bob said:

David,

It's possible Daniel Dufrene will be the starter. I don't have a final answer yet and probably won't get it until later in the week. If it isn't Daniel, it will be Jason Ford. Make me guess and I'd say Dufrene will start.
Troy Pollard is healthy again and is ready for more work. Besides recovering from knee surgery, he also had a high ankle sprain to come back from. With Mikel Leshoure out for the season, Pollard will get more carries.

Bob

BigT from Philo, IL — 12:40 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

I think it would be better if the schedule table on IlliniHQ.com's basketball page had links to the box score and show the cumulative record. Is this possible?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:42 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

BigT- Good idea. I'll see if that's possible -- shouldn't be a problem.

Thanks. If anyone has ideas or complaints about IlliniHQ.com, feel free to send them to sports editor Jim Rossow (jrossow@news-gazette.com) or Paul Klee (pklee@news-gazette.com).

Klee

Jesse from Billings, MT — 12:42 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

If you had to pick a clear-cut leader on this years team who would you say that person is? Do you believe Coach Web would agree?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:45 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Jesse- Can't tell you how much I miss fishing the Big Horn River outside Billings. The black caddis hatch in August - awesome.

The team's leader, at this point, is Chester Frazier. He will be named a captain. The coaches would like to see Demetri McCamey move into that role, and they want to name him a captain, too. But Weber said the sophomore has to earn it.

Klee

Mitch from Champaign,, IL — 12:46 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Hey Paul,

You and I have talked a few times about recruiting. I respect your opinion tremendously. What do you think of the commitment of Shaun Pratl to EIU? I know this isn't Illini related but I thought i would ask since EIU is my alma mater.

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:52 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Mitch- Thanks. Shaun Pratl is a very good get for EIU. He's a big, tough kid, probably 6-6 and 230. With that kind of a frame, he's ready-made to make an early impact in the OVC. Truthfully, I wasn't sure if he would pursue college basketball or football.

Shaun was an honorable mention News-Gazette All-Stater last season. Wouldn't surprise me if he's in contention for one of the 15 first-team spots this season.

Big recruiting pull by Mike Miller and his staff.

Klee

John from Urbana, IL — 12:53 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Paul,

any big surprises for you over the first few weeks of practice and the first exhibition game?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:55 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

John- I detailed the biggest surprise on IlliniHQ.com, on my blog, yesterday. I have been and will be updating the blog every day, so check back from time to time.

Richard Semrau is the biggest surprise. To quote Bruce Weber, "There's no doubt."

Klee

Geno from Warrenton, Missouri — 12:55 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Paul I thought Semura looked pretty good,as the season gets going can you see him becoming a bigger factor with regards to minutes,maybe even starting?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 12:58 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Geno- To quote former Wyoming coach Steve McClain, "Again, there's no doubt."

Richard Semrau has turned the corner; the next step is applying it over a two- or three-game stretch. The next step, as one assistant said yesterday, is to "punch back when he gets punched." Don't take that literally. And it's probably a bad choice of words in these circles, at the moment. But you know what I'm saying. Bruce Weber wants the big men to get tougher.

Here's some of what Richard Semrau told me yesterday at Ubben.

"This is my time to prove myself, in practice. Every time I come out here I treat it like it's the time when I have to prove myself to the coaches," he said. "The exhibition games to me are no different than practice, they just mean a little more. If I show them that I understand our system and understand our offense so they trust me."

Measure your expectations for the third-year sophomore. But Semrau can make a difference. He weighed in at 243 pounds yesterday, and he's 6-10.

You can read more Richard Semrau on IlliniHQ.com. And there will be more on him in Sunday's News-Gazette.

Klee

Bill from Kirksville, MO — 01:00 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Is there any chance that Bill Cole redshirts?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:04 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Bill- Not at the moment, but I like where your head's at. I'm a proponent of not redshirting freshmen, but redshirting sophomores, if you're going to redshirt someone. By then you know what you have, and if he's a guy you want for five years.

Bill Cole has had a tough run thus far. There was the shoulder injury before the Canada trip last year, then the shin injury that cut short his freshman season.

(On a sidenote: the injury Cole suffered, he said, is similar to what Tyler Hansbrough is dealing with.)

Bill Cole told me yesterday he was about three games over the NCAA's limit for a medical redshirt. But he has returned to the court after sustaining an ankle injury last week. He was taped and he wore a brace yesterday, but is hoping to go with one or the other in the second exhibition game on Sunday.

I asked him yesterday where he thinks he stands, in regards to the playing rotation.

"I just want to get a solid spot in the rotation. Like I said before, I just want to help the team win," Cole said. "I think the ankle injury might have set me back, because this is the time when people are claiming their spots. But I think I can bounce back from that. It

Art from Mahomet, Il — 01:05 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Paul,

What have you heard about Parkland's prospects for this year. I heard their new coaches used to play a litle basketball...

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:11 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Art- Good to hear from you. Parkland and first-year coach Sergio McClain are 1-1 at this point. He will have to juggle a small lineup this season; there are a pair of 6-6 guys, but that's it in terms of size.

This is going to be a project, but I think they will be competitive a year from now. Sergio's name should help recruiting, and Marcus Griffin is an assistant. The Parkland guys often played pickup games at Ubben over the summer.

My question: How about the Orange Krush visits Parkland for one of the first games? Sergio McClain stood in the Krush last season - perhaps they could return the favor.

Talk to you later, Art.

Klee

Mitch from Champaign, IL — 01:13 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

What Freshmen nationally will make the most impact this year?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:18 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Mitch- Ohio State's B.J. Mullens is the Big Ten's best freshman.

Steve from Urbana, IL — 01:19 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

I have high hopes for Mike Tisdale this season. But, fouls seemed to limit his minutes in several games last season (IU, MSU, PUR, PSU, etc.). Last season Mike Tisdale averaged 1 foul every 7.4 min. (obviously fouls aren't distributed evenly). With avg. minutes expected to more than double this year (from 10.4 avg to 20+ avg.), is this a concern of the coaching staff or am i just overreaching?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:20 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Steve- You're not over-reaching. That's something I wrote about on HQ before the first exhibition game. Mike Tisdale fouls too much. It happens in practice, it happens in games. He had three fouls in the first three minutes of a practice scrimmage last week, and he fouled out in 15 minutes on Sunday.

The big guy has potential, but not if he's saddled with foul trouble. He knows that. Illinois needs him on the court.

Klee

Smokin' Joe from Andalusia, IL — 01:21 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Klee: I know everyone has an opinion on redshirts but I truly believe that Simpson would be better off taking one this year. With Tis, Cole, Davis, Keller and CJ Jackson we have 5 bigs that we could use if need be(though I doubt Jackson is in any rotation).

With the upcoming Illinois classes so guard heavy it would sure be nice to have Simpson around for 4 years after this one. Simpson, Griffey and Leonard would be a great inside nucleous for the next several years to go along with the great guards coming in.

What are your thoughts?

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:25 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Smokin' Joe- My thoughts: Sounds like a solid story idea for Sunday's N-G. And how about we include Loren Tate's list of "10 Illinois Freshman Who Should Have Redshirted."

Stan Simpson doesn't want to redshirt. He said as much again yesterday. It's an interesting dilemma for Illinois; he excels in the spotlight (in games) but has faced the normal freshmen struggles in practice sessions.

Simpson had six points and six boards in seven minutes against Florida Southern.

"I think I played good for the time I

Clay from Eads, Tennessee — 01:26 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Taking advantage of a NCAA rule change effective last season, the Memphis Tigers have played closed scrimmages with other Division I-A schools each of the last two seasons in place of an exhibition game. Fans and media are not allowed to watch and the coaches can only make the most general of comments about the scrimmage afterwards.

Has Coach Weber thought about holding such a closed scrimmage, perhaps against his old team, Southern Illinois? It would seem that he would get a better gage on his team than he would with the current exhibition games against Division II schools.

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:28 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Clay- It's a great rule. The best closed-scrimmage matchup this preseason will take place Saturday in Denver: Gonzaga vs. Texas.

That looks more like a Sweet 16 game than a scrimmage.

Unless something changes, Illinois and SIU will not play each other, as long as Bruce Weber and Chris Lowery are the coaches at the respective schools. Lowery doesn't want to face Weber; Weber doesn't want to face Lowery. It's mutual. They're too close.

Look for the Salukis to start two freshmen this season: Ryan Hare and Kevin Dillard. Bryan Mullins' leadership is a gift for those young guys -- I hope they take advantage of it.

Lowery suspended Hare for their exhibition opener -- complacency in the classroom doesn't sit well with those guys -- but the Marshall product has a chance to be a very good one in C'Dale. He's a winner.

Clay, I'll check for you on potential scrimmages for Illinois. Thanks for reminding me.

Klee

Al C from Danville, IL — 01:30 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Hi Paul;
I hear that the players are buying into their roles this year. Some of the players last Sunday seem to have a ways to go as far as buying into their roles. Once all the players buy in then this season should be successful.

My question is: What do you see as Bill Cole's role?

Thanks for your reply,

AL C

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:34 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Al- Billy Cole is a realist when it comes to playing time. The formula, in his mind, is simple.

"If you do what the coaches want you to do, you're going to get minutes on this team," he said.

Remember, Bill Cole was flirting with a starting role going into last season. Injuries have bothered him, and that's been frustrating, but this isn't an established frontcourt where minutes are thin. There are minutes to be had.

Bill Cole injured the same ankle when he was in high school at Peoria Richwoods.

"That's probably why it's loose," he said yesterday. But other than that, he said, he did not experience injuries prior to his arrival at Illinois.

An extended period sans injuries would go a long way toward Cole establishing a spot in the playing rotation.

Klee

Paul Klee (moderator) — 01:38 PM on Wed, 11/05/2008

Going to wrap this up. Exceptional chat today, thanks for all the questions. Check back throughout the week for Illinois basketball updates on IlliniHQ.com.

The first two people to email Klee (pklee@news-gazette.com) with their take on the Iverson-Billups trade get tickets to Sunday's exhibition game at the Assembly Hall.

And congratulations to Dr. Dan Grossman for finishing med school. Do something special.

Klee