IlliniHQ.com: Your Illini Sports Headquarters
Advertisement

Previous Entries

Advertisement

On Women's Basketball

The Destiny Watch

Posted by: Tony Bleill

Thursday, November 19, 2009 4:38 PM

If Illinois is a team of destiny, it will be without Destiny. Or so it appears.

In Wednesday's postgame press conference, I asked coach Jolette Law about the chances that Destiny Williams won't play again this season. Law, who issued a pregame statement through the school's sports information department, didn't appear terribly happy to be answering a question about her star recruit, but said she would "doubt if she plays" this season. After a follow-up question by another reporter, a UI spokesman immediately jumped in and ended the proceedings. This is as much transparency as UI fans are likely to see, at least for a little while.

Here are one person's opinions, such as they are, on the good, bad and ugly of the Williams situation and how it seemingly has transpired:

Positives:

--On the court, Williams' absence will reduce the team's depth, but that's about it. Granted, any team would be better with a McDonald's All-American on the roster. But the Illini have an emerging star in Karisma Penn for the 4 spot, which is where most of Williams' minutes would have emanated from. She wasn't going to play much at the 3 -- that's Lacey Simpson's spot. Penn has done little wrong so far and it's hard to envision Williams producing more than Penn has to this point. Brianna Jones adds depth, and Law has consistently raved about an improved Lana Rukavina, though to this point that hasn't translated into increased playing time for the sophomore (5 minutes in a lopsided win on Wednesday).

--The team's chemistry won't be disrupted. It's unclear how well Williams and her teammates were getting along. Williams spent a portion of the summer with the U.S. U19 team, pulling her away from her teammates, who spent the summer sessions in Champaign. If her absence then had any impact on the bonding process, who knows? But it certainly appears the Illini have some good chemistry brewing right now, and this move means there won't be a chance of it being altered until ... well ... at some later point. If then.

Negatives:

--Obviously, this has the potential of being a P.R. nightmare for the program. Anytime one of the nation's top 10 recruits is in this position, it's news. Fans are wondering what's going on. Potential recruits, common sense suggests, would be curious about the situation before making any decisions regarding Illinois. And placed on top of the Danyel Crutcher and Lori Bjork sagas, Williams' potential departure from the program, if it were to happen, would be another thing that rival recruiters would throw against the Illini. You can rest assured of that.

--If Williams does return next season, she'll have only three seasons of eligibility because the Illini burned this one. Williams played seven minutes in the season opener, which means she can't redshirt. (A medical redshirt candidate is allowed to play up to 20 percent of a team's games.) 

I'll be a guest on Saturday Sportsline (10 a.m. WDWS) to talk about Williams and UI hoops. The podcast should be available on IlliniHQ later in the day.

As for Wednesday's win, the Illini brutalized CMU inside to take command, and Jenna Smith's and Penn's numbers show the damage. Law wasn't pleased with her team's second-half play. I can't comment much on that subject; because of tight deadlines, I was writing for much of the half and didn't see all the specifics, but I looked up enough from my computer to see some sloppy ballhandling, which remains the No. 1 priority before the Big Ten season arrives. 

Macie Blinn's sharp three-point shooting has to be encouraging for the Illini, along with the developing consistency of Penn. 

 

Comments

Relax about Destiny Williams. No one in CU knew about her until the coach recruited her. I am sure the coach would love to keep her. If I were a coach I would want my players to do what I wanted as opposed to 12 players doing their own thing. So Illini fans please just relax and let the Coach do her work without the grumbling.

Posted by Jam on November 20, 2009 at 9:21 PM

So Destiny is going to transfer somewhere where a coach will handle her better.

Posted by RPeterE on November 21, 2009 at 2:08 PM

Wonder if "Big Sis" Jenna Smith really looked after Destiny or just was shunned.

Posted by RPeterE on November 21, 2009 at 2:12 PM

A scholarship is a contract between the University and the player. It is a huge step from high school that brings a lot of demands such as going to class, working long hours in practice, and bending to the demands of others. It is a job to be a student-athlete (male or female). It requires effort. Relationships are important, but the student-athlete needs to remember that he/she made a commitment. If someone cannot handle this then yes they should move to somewhere else where perhaps they can do better.

Posted by Jam on November 23, 2009 at 8:22 AM

It's easy to cite the rules and contractual legalese but reality is that you have individuals with their own unique needs and expectations. Everyone is different and some just need extra counseling, extra attention, extra effort. Coaches and college sports administrators should know that and be willing to accommodate athletes with extra needs. This isn't communism.

Posted by RPeterE on November 23, 2009 at 12:54 PM

Really, the community hype worries me as much or more than whether we get the big player. Remember the big, bad saga between Allison Curtin and Coach Grenz? The SAD thing is, people stayed away from Illinois WBB in droves, because they "didn't like" coach Grentz, and really, most of us knew precious little about the situation. I am trying not to judge. But, I do agree with the observation of Coach Grentz, that women are less able to "get away with" being outspoken and opinionated. Jeff Jordan waffled about this year, and nobody is saying "it is because Bruce Webber is a difficult person". I think both the female coaches and female players are more heavily judged than male coaches or players.

I do think that Destiny should think long and hard about spending an entire year of eligibity on seven minutes of basketball!

Posted by Donna on November 27, 2009 at 9:26 PM

the redshirt rule should be changed. Its not fair to the player to only play for 7 minutes in your first game and that blows your redshirt year.

Posted by dave1956 on November 28, 2009 at 2:16 PM

I am glad to have found your blog Tony. It is nice to be able to read about the team.

I support coach Law in all she does as the Illini coach. I like her style. She reminds me of Coach Summitt at Tennessee and C Viv at Rutgers with her discipline.

One player is not bigger than the team.

Perhaps Destiny should buy into coach Law's system and come back to the team with a new attitude. I would think she would by accepted back if she came back ready to abide by the team rules. The season is young. She does not have to lose a year of eligibility if she makes things right.

If she thinks Illinois is no longer a good fit for her then so be it. Let her find the proper fit at another school. I wish her well either way.

Posted by KMarie on November 29, 2009 at 12:22 PM

I think the kids leave the colleges a lot more than they used to.

Good coaches are not easy people, in some respects. Think Pat Summitt is easygoing? Last year Tennesse fielded the fourth youngest squad in the country; somebody - several somebodies - left that program! I'll bet Gene-O from UConn is not easygoing either. We all know Vivian Stringer does things like take uniforms. She is also very successful.

Posted by Donna on December 4, 2009 at 10:13 PM

Add a Comment

Create an account

I forgot my password